It's now been eight months since I got my first Apple notebook. A few months ago I wrote about my initial opinion, where I was pretty sure it would be my last Apple notebook too.
Since then I've had the chance to use it in a variety of situations. Spoiler: none of what I've seen has improved my opinion of it one bit.
Edit (25/1): Two inline updates.
Since then I've had the chance to use it in a variety of situations. Spoiler: none of what I've seen has improved my opinion of it one bit.
- The decision to make the outer body out of aluminium is literally shocking. If the notebook isn't plugged in to a grounded socket (for instance, if I'm using the plug that comes with the power brick BY DEFAULT), I'm liable to get electric shocks if I touch the casing. I received a couple of shocks, a mild one and a jolting one, before I realized what was happening. Electrical common sense is that if the outer surface is electrically conducting, it MUST be grounded properly. Having an ungrounded plug by default, or even having one in the first place, is inexcusable. (Update: I've had several people complain to me about this, and one person also complain about his plastic macbook's screws shocking him several times. I'm clearly not the only one with this issue.)
- The Wi-Fi reception is the worst I've ever seen in a laptop, and only slightly better than the reception my Nexus S with its puny little antenna gets. Friends tell me it's because the aluminium casing acts as a Faraday cage and attenuates the signal. The "unibody" marketing's clearly far more important to Apple than shipping a working product. (Update: guess who says metal has a "very high" potential to interfere with wireless connections?)
- The original power adapters were T-shaped. However, presumably because Apple didn't like the look of and subsequently didn't include the strain-relieving flexes found on all other cables, they were easily frayed. To "fix" this, they started using L-shaped adapters. Of course, what it now means is that depending on the way I insert it, either the power cord blocks the Ethernet port or it gets subjected to strain if I tilt the notebook back.
- There's no VGA, DVI or HDMI port, so I need to carry around a set of three dongles everywhere I go. There's plenty of space on the left side, too, so that's not an excuse.
- The lack of working sleep is more annoying than I thought it would be. Amazingly, the EFI equivalent to the POST takes almost as long as Windows resuming from hibernation. A few people seem to be working on getting Windows to boot via EFI, and my hopes are mostly pinned on that.
Edit (25/1): Two inline updates.
6 comments:
Strange. My aluminium unibody macbook pro has been in front of me for a few years now.
1. never got any electrical shock. I seriously suggest you take your laptop back to an apple store...
2. over the years, I had dell, hp, lenovo and apple laptops. My macbookpro is in the top 3 for wifi reception.
3. I torture my T magsafe adapter all day long, during my business trips. Never happened to me. And trust me, I do torture them.
4. true. On another note, I am glad the laptop does not use extra space for 2 or 3 difference video interfaces while I never used more than one.
5. my OS X Lion MBP goes to and from sleep almost instantaneously
1. I really doubt it's a problem with the laptop itself, given that I know others with the same problem. *Regardless*, I now think selling a high-value and delicate electronic good with a 2-pin plug should be illegal and grounds for heavy fines.
3. There was a class-action lawsuit in the US about this: http://techcrunch.com/2011/11/10/class-action-lawsuit-forces-apple-to-replace-frayed-magsafe-power-cords/
5. My previous post has some context.
ive got a Sony Vaio and its carbon, thus conductive, but I don't get shocks even without ground on the power supply. It's properly made. The carbon still acts as the shield too!
It always amazed me (in the wrong way) how Apple laptops actually may shock you. (also annoys me every time).
For the last point I believe that all macs now go into deep sleep (aka hibernation) for various reasons (power and security) by default after some minutes (it goes into regular sleep first, then write to disk a few minutes later and powers itself off). You can actually change that to have instant wake up.
ps: wheres my browserid prompt ;-)
re last point: Windows has that too, but it's not related -- my previous post has information why.
BrowserID: I'm looking at switching to Wordpress to get BrowserID :)
The last macbook pro I had did have pretty poor wifi reception compared to the ThinkPads I had before and after the MBP.
Also, the power cord connector did fray, though not obviously so -- it just started giving me shocks one day. Eventually it started to melt and burned a spot on my desk.
Asa: wow, that's pretty bad.
Post a Comment